Too Good to Be True

by Rev. Fred G. Garry - December 3, 2000
Texts: I Kings 19 and Luke I

    There is a challenge in life we can often miss. For in the hustle and bustle, in the day's duties, the schedules, and the expectations, it is a challenge that demands we put all these aside. And this is a challenge where we must also put aside our very selves. We must not only put away our work, but also the definitions we have worked hard to craft. Definitions of right and wrong, definitions of how long it will take, who should be given what, and why. There is such a challenge, a challenge we often miss. For the cost is great, and the risk is great as well, leading many to balk when the opportunity presents itself.
    I stood with a colleague recently who was brimming with excitement. He is leading a new, dramatically emerging ministry and its going well. He began to describe some the events: good numbers, good enthusiasm, good support from the parent group sponsoring the ministry. What could be better? He then shifted gears and described a whole series of personal tragedies he had recently faced: a son whose broken arm required surgery twice, a brother-in-law losing all in a flood, and something else that was too difficult to talk about, but was conveyed as an understanding. And then, back to the ministry.
    He was filled with joy. "A man came to me after a recent service," he said. "He walked up to me with tears in his eyes and said, 'in your words was the first time I had ever experienced grace. I never really knew what it was.'" Preacher-types live for moments like this. He went on to describe some other moments of deep joy in his new ministry, but then he stopped short. It was as if he was hearing himself speaking out loud, and he said, "well, I better stop. I don't want to sound too Pollyanna, about this." His statement took me back a bit and I said, "you don't have to stop for me, I like Pollyanna."
    I have wondered a lot about his comment since, "I don't want to sound like Pollyanna." I mean it would have been one thing to say, "I don't want to be Pollyanna," but to sound like her. This intrigues me. The story of Pollyanna should leave many not wanting her life. The novel depicting her life doesn't leave much room for wanting her lot. She is born into abject poverty; she is last of three children born to a husband and wife and the only one who survives early childhood. She lives with her parents and then only with her father as her mother dies. They live on the dismal charity of others, often referred to as "what the Ladies Aiders gave us in barrels."
    Living with her father, having lost all other family, far from any one, or any place of beauty, Pollyanna expressed her desire to have a doll. To have a doll was her heart's desire, from which we can deduce that she grew up with no toys, no belongs, to treasures. Our children today could never imagine this, both for good and ill. But this was her desire and her desire prompted her father to write the missionary board, who sends them their paltry support, requesting a doff. In response the board sent a pair of children's crutches. The crutches, the board explains, were the only child item they had, so they would have to suffice instead of a doll.
    Out of this grave disappointment, for Pollyanna was crushed, from the crutches comes the famous "Glad Game." Her father, seeing Pollyanna crushed with disappointment says, "well we should be glad. Why should we be glad? Well, because you don't have to use them. Your legs work and for that we should be glad. "It was just absurd enough to work. And from that moment on Pollyanna learns to play the "Glad Game." Any and every circumstance that ought to produce disappointment is met with the challenge of trying to find something better to be happy about. And in Pollyanna's life she played this game everyday, for it wasn't long after this that her father dies as well.
    Now this is just the beginning of her story depicted in the novel bearing her name. The rest of the story is built upon the reality that a grieving child who is bereft of all those who had loved her was sent to a woman who for all intents and purposes was incapable of love. Rich in material things, but poor in spiritual ones, the child is thrown into a regiment of duty and aloof detachment known as Aunt Polly. You see I could have understood if my colleague had said, "I don't want to be Pollyanna." For no one would choose to lose their siblings, their parents, and be put in the charge of an uncaring person whose bitterness ruled her soul.
    I just can't see someone looking at the young girl's life and saying, "ya, sure, I will take this. I'll be Pollyanna." But this is not what he said, nor what he meant. He said, "I don't want to sound Eke Pollyanna." And this statement intrigues me. For in spite of everything the amazing thing about Pollyanna, and what it means to be a Pollyanna, is that she was happy, she was glad. In fact she said the word "glad" so often that her aunt forbade her to use the word. She forbade her until it became obvious that the poor child could no longer speak. So often was she prone to use the word "glad" that her diction became halted and confusing as she groped for another word in her common talk.
    So the option that is left and the question that comes with it is this: could my colleague, by saying "I don't want to sound like Pollyanna," could he have meant that he didn't to sound glad, sound joyful, sound like someone who is happy in spite of challenge, loss, grief even? Could this be what he meant? I dare say there is no other option, but what a queer one. To say, "I don't want to sound happy; I don't want to speak with a transcending joy" when in fact that is what he was. Why not sound like it? Why play small, hide your happiness?
    There is a challenge in Iife, a challenge I believe we often miss. For to rise to the challenge we have to lay aside our understandings and our duties. To step up to the challenge demands we let our heart loose. Unfettered from defenses and coping skills often meant to keep a steady course, we are called to let our spirit sow for a moment. Such a challenge doesn't come every day it seems, but at particular moments, particular moments that are never really perfect.
    Such a lack of perfection was what kept Zechariah tied to the ground. He was too old; his wife was too old. All that the angel said sounded great, amazing even. "But is there some proof, something that will tell me this is true. For this sounds too good to be true." And as the Bible often does he couples Zechariah with a larger picture, a larger refusal to believe. For the angel not only tells Zechariah that his life will be freed from disappointment, that the long lasting moment of disgrace Elizabeth had faced will be taken away, but so will the disgrace of Israel be taken away. Their son will be the spirit of Elijah, the one who runs ahead, the one who announces the joy of God's forgiveness and mercy.
    For the passage we read from I Kings, this passage is where Elijah got what we would call a nickname, the one who prepares the way, the one who goes ahead. Elijah out runs a chariot, giving it a head start, on a thirty-mile trek over hills and valleys from Mount Carmel to Jezreel. He out runs Ahab to say, "the drought is over, the punishment is done, eat drink and be merry." So when the angel came to Zechariah he told him, "your son is going to be Elijah; he is going to run ahead of the people and tell them good news; the drought of mercy is over." And to this Zechariah says, "you know, no offence, but I am old, and my wife is old, how do I know this for sure?"
    There is a challenge in life we so often miss. We miss it as we look to our circumstances, our limitations, our disappointments. We miss the challenge as we say to ourselves, "we had better be sure, look before we leap. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. I should not give a false impression. I shouldn't paint such a rosy picture; life has a way of defeating us, of casting our hopes to the ground. So it would be best not to hope too much, not to dream too big. That would be best, lest we sound too much like Pollyanna."
    One year in the church I served in Ohio, the deacons asked me for a special Christmas project. I told them about a local ministry that worked with troubled youth. It was a residency program; an intensive rehab run by a very charismatic pastor who had grown up on the streets of New York, living the life many of his charges lived, but by grace he had recovered and now dedicated his life to helping others. The project was to provide a Christmas party for the young men, complete with gifts, refreshments and fellowship at the church.
    It is fair to say the deacons were nervous about the young men in the program. Most of these young men were there in lieu of jail. They had lived on the rough edges of Iife, destroying their lives with drugs and alcohol. What would the deacons have to say to them? Would the evening be a long, awkward time of polite conversation? Fears or not, the evening came for the gathering. There were twelve young men in the program at the time and they arrived with four leaders about 7:00. The group was brought into the sanctuary, bedecked for Advent. Beneath the tree in the sanctuary there were stacks of presents. For the deacons had gotten clothing sizes and preferences and descriptions of the young men and bought them gifts.
    After some opening remarks and a prayer, each deacon located the young man they had bought gifts for. With this identification, they quickly went back to the tree and retrieved their stack. Each one as they approached the young men was given a long confused gaze, and then a kind of hazy acceptance by each one. Each one of them put their stack of presents to the side, looking to the leaders, looking to me. Then one of the ladies said, "sweetheart these are for you. Merry Christmas." And having opening no gifts, the young man having been bid "sweetheart" began to weep.
    And then for what seemed Eke an eternity each one of them unwrapped their gifts. Finally one of them stood opened gift in hand and said, "this is the first time I have been away from MY family. What I did was wrong, and I deserve to be punished. But I thought being away from my family at Christmas time was going to do me in. But you have given me a Christmas, you have given me so much more than I deserve." And then everybody cried!
And the deacon's fears, well let's just say, they weren't realized. For as they sat next to the young men they found they did know them well. They were the children they had tried to raise, they were the sons lost and found, they were the children of God just like them. In the years following that one, the evening with Outreach for Youth came to out shine all other the special events of Advent. It came to be a moment above all the others, for without a doubt, it was always an amazing moment of joy. For each year there was a new set of young men who were surprised that someone could be gracious without reserve.
    There is a challenge in life we often miss. The challenge of running ahead of others proclaiming joy. The challenge of sounding as happy as you are. There is a deep and abiding challenge to believe in the love of God and let your words be filled with the sounds and power of this gift, and not to play it small.
    It is one thing to not want the life of Pollyanna, but for all intents and purposes, it is our calling to sound like her. For what is the church but the sound of joy in the midst of sorrow, the sound of gladness in the midst of brokenness, the sound of love in the midst of despair? What is the church but the ones who run ahead like Elijah, like John, like Gabriel and say, "do I have good news for you? This is a gift for you. Sweetheart these are for you. Merry Christmas."
    In the days ahead you are going to meet moments of opportunity to run ahead, to dream out loud, to hope in the midst of disappointment, do it. Take the leap, the risk, play the glad game if you dare. If you find someone, especially someone who sees their life as less, treat them as more. Don't give into the voice of decorum, or the voice of "that is too much." Brothers and sisters, Christmas time is the season of God's lavish, spectacular gift of love. This is the time to dare, to be the sound of love of joy. This is the time where we become the hymn, "Joy to the World." Amen.

Return to Sermons Contents